One of the core investment strategies we often discuss with our clients is buying dividend-paying stocks. These stocks provide income through regular dividend payments. One of the most important measures to understand is the dividend yield. Dividend yield helps you see how much income you’re getting from your investment relative to the stock’s price.

To make smart decisions about dividend stocks, it’s important to understand how dividend yield is calculated, what a good yield looks like, when a yield might be too high, and why chasing high yields can sometimes backfire. Here’s a breakdown to help guide you.

Dividend Yield Formula

Let’s start with the basics. Dividend yield is calculated using a simple formula:

Dividend Yield = Annual Dividends per Share ÷ Stock Price × 100 %

This formula gives you a percentage that shows how much return you’re earning in the form of dividends. For example, if a stock pays $2 in annual dividends and the current stock price is $40, the dividend yield would be:

2 ÷ 40 x 100 = 5%

That means for every dollar you invest, you earn 5 cents in dividend income per year, or 5%. This percentage makes it easier to compare the income potential of different stocks.

How Does Dividend Yield Work?

Dividend yield tells you how much income you’re getting from a stock compared to its price. When a company shares its profits with investors through dividends, the yield helps you measure how generous those payments are.

A higher dividend yield means more income for every dollar invested. This is especially appealing to investors who want consistent income—such as retirees or anyone focused on building cash flow from their portfolio.

What Is a Good Dividend Yield?

A “good” dividend yield depends on your goals, risk tolerance, and what other investment options are available. In general, a good yield is one that offers solid income without taking on too much risk. It should also be backed by a company with healthy financials and a history of maintaining or increasing its dividends.

Many investors look for yields that are higher than the average stock or better than what they could earn from a savings account or a bond. However, yield alone doesn’t make a stock a smart choice—you’ll also want to look at the company’s overall stability and growth potential.

What Dividend Yield Is Too High?

While high yields can be tempting, they can sometimes signal trouble. A dividend yield that’s much higher than the average in its industry may be a warning sign.

This could happen if a company’s stock price drops sharply, which increases the yield, or if the company is overpromising and paying out more than it can sustain. According to NerdWallet, any yield over 4% should be looked at more carefully, and anything above 10% should be considered a red flag.

Drawbacks of Chasing High Dividend Yields

Although high dividend income sounds great, there are some real downsides to watch for:

• Lower Growth: Companies with high dividend yields often reinvest less money into growing the business.
• Financial Struggles: A very high yield may point to a company that’s not managing its finances well or can’t afford to invest in future opportunities.
• Poor Market Sentiment: If a yield is unusually high, it might scare off investors who see it as a sign of instability.
• Dividend Cuts: When companies face financial trouble, dividends are often the first thing to be reduced or eliminated. This can hurt both the income you receive and the stock’s price.

While dividend yield is a useful tool for evaluating income potential, it shouldn’t be the only factor you consider. Balancing yield with company quality, consistency, and long-term outlook is key—especially for investors planning for retirement. By understanding how dividend yield works and knowing the risks of reaching for too much yield, you’ll be better equipped to make smart, sustainable investment choices.

Read more: What Is A Good Relative Strength For A Stock?